Justice Nakachwa: Reliable Forensic Evidence Is Key to Preventing Wrongful Convictions
The training, the fifth in the series, brought together participants from the Western Region Clusters One and Two, Central, Northern and Eastern regions. The sessions were moderated by HW Juliet Harty Hatanga, Deputy Registrar, JTI, assisted by HW Khadija Kahunde, Magistrate, JTI.
Delivering the closing remarks on behalf of the JTI Governing Council Chairperson, Justice Florence Nakachwa of the Court of Appeal commended participants for their active engagement and urged them to apply the knowledge acquired to promote fair and evidence-based adjudication.
Justice Nakachwa described forensic science as an indispensable tool in criminal justice, enabling courts to establish facts, reconstruct events and assess the credibility of evidence presented during trials.
She highlighted key forensic techniques, including DNA profiling, toxicology, ballistics, tool mark identification, digital analysis and chemical examination, noting that scientific methods can corroborate or challenge witness testimony and assist courts in reaching informed decisions.
She stressed that the justice system is not merely about securing convictions, but fundamentally about delivering justice. Reliable forensic evidence, she noted, is critical to protecting innocent persons from wrongful convictions while ensuring that offenders are held accountable.
Citing Proverbs 17:15, which condemns both acquitting the guilty and condemning the innocent, Justice Nakachwa reminded Judicial Officers of their responsibility to uphold fairness and integrity in the administration of justice.
She urged Judicial Officers to scrutinise expert testimony carefully and seek clarification whenever technical evidence or terminology is unclear. Asking relevant questions during proceedings, she observed, enables courts to better understand complex scientific evidence and properly evaluate the facts before reaching a decision.
Drawing from her experience at the Court of Appeal, Justice Nakachwa noted that appellate courts re-evaluate evidence presented during trial to determine whether it was properly assessed and the applicable legal principles correctly applied. She cautioned that inadequate evaluation of scientific evidence at trial can undermine the integrity of the final decision.
The Justice also emphasised the need for Judicial Officers to observe proper procedures in plea bargaining, noting that a guilty plea must be carefully examined to establish the offence to which an accused person is admitting guilt.
She explained that Judicial Officers must ensure that the plea is unequivocal, that the accused understands the charges and relevant facts, and that the sentence imposed is appropriate to the offence and consistent with the law. Plea bargaining, she stressed, should not be reduced to merely recording convictions, but must remain a lawful process that safeguards the rights of accused persons.
Justice Nakachwa welcomed the participation of officers from the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) and the Inspectorate of Government, noting that effective use of forensic evidence requires coordinated handling across the justice chain. Weaknesses at any stage, from the collection and presentation of evidence to its evaluation in court, can contribute to miscarriages of justice.
Looking ahead, Justice Nakachwa revealed that the JTI Governing Council had asked the Institute to consider introducing a moot court exercise on forensic evidence. The proposed practical session would give participants an opportunity to experience how forensic evidence is presented, challenged through objections and examined by a court in a realistic courtroom setting.
She commended the JTI leadership, under Executive Director Justice Prof. Andrew Khaukha, for organising the training and sustaining efforts to build the capacity of Judicial Officers across the country. She also appreciated facilitators from the Uganda Police Force, medical professionals and other experts for sharing their knowledge and practical experience.
Justice Nakachwa urged participants to remain committed to continuous professional development and apply the skills acquired at their respective stations.
She concluded by reminding participants that the ultimate objective of criminal adjudication is to ensure that convictions are founded on reliable evidence, innocent persons are protected and public confidence in the justice system is maintained.
Posted 13th, October 2026